A Brief History of Behavioral Approaches to Suffering
Understanding and addressing psychological suffering has been a central concern in the Western world for over a century. Different approaches have emerged over time, each attempting to offer solutions to the complex issue of human suffering.
This article provides a concise overview of the evolution of behavioral approaches to suffering, tracing their development from psychoanalysis to cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and finally to the more recent advancements in relational frame theory (RFT).
The Psychoanalytic Era
At the turn of the twentieth century, psychoanalysis, pioneered by figures like Sigmund Freud, dominated the field of psychology. This approach posited that suffering resulted from unresolved unconscious conflicts and desires that conflicted with societal norms. To address this suffering, psychoanalysts developed techniques such as free association and dream interpretation.
However, these methods were time-consuming and not accessible to many patients, especially those in medical settings. This is especially true in today’s world.
The Rise of Behavioral Approaches
As scientific efforts to address psychological problems advanced, behavioral approaches emerged. Behaviorists like John B. Watson focused on observing and modifying observable human behaviors.
They introduced principles derived from laboratory-based studies, such as operant and classical conditioning. While they recognized the importance of mental activity, they did not attempt to predict or control cognition or language because direct observation was challenging.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)
With the advent of computers and the idea of the human mind as a powerful information processor, cognitive-behavioral theorists proposed that distorted, irrational thinking and poor problem-solving skills were the causes of mental suffering.
CBT aimed to teach patients to eliminate thinking errors and develop better problem-solving abilities, with the hope of reducing self-defeating behaviors. CBT became the first psychological treatment to undergo rigorous clinical trials. Although it showed promise in reducing symptoms associated with mental disorders, it didn't systematically measure patient functioning or quality of life.
In fact, it is possible to meet the objectives set forth in volumes of protocol and still have a client end all interventions and still be subject to suffering with the same issues that initially brought them in. Just think of your own practice.
The Emergence of Relational Frame Theory (RFT)
In recent years, behavioral science has returned to the work of B.F. Skinner and behavior analysis. Radical behaviorists explored the idea that human language and thought operate under similar principles as observable behavior. This led to the development of relational frame theory (RFT), a model that sheds light on how we develop thoughts, associate emotions with memories, and create rules that govern our behavior in response to imagined events and their consequences.
Key Implications of RFT
RFT research has uncovered crucial clinical insights:
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to RhodeIslandACT to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.